Anyone who's ever had a passing interest in media and the ethical politics that come with it, should see this movie. I'm not sure I agree with all the decisions the director made for Meryl Streep's character, but it was extremely well written and very timely.
Even though I should know better by now, I still tend to fall back into that assumption that when a newspaper or TV newscast releases a story, it's a) true, and b) the whole story. I know that's naive, but even when I'm writing my own news stories, I never consciously think about the fact that someone else might look at my story and point out that I left out pertinent information that might have changed the shape of the story. Everyone leaves out details when they write up an article. You have to. How many times have our profs reminded us -- if your editor asks for 12 inches and you write 20, they won't read the rest of the story just to see what else was going on. They'll chop it off the end. So it's in your best interest to get all the important info into the first 12 inches, and being concise is just a skill you need to develop.
Clearly not one I excel at.
The point is, in the interest of saving space, all news stories are limited. The problem arises when individual humans make the decision to include or exclude particular details of each story. Every reporter would write the same story differently, based on the facts and viewpoints he or she thinks matter the most.
But what about when the decision isn't just which facts to include, but whether to run a story at all? This movie looked at the role the media played in "selling" the Iraq war to the American public. The director's argument, if I got it right, was that the media simply took any and all information the government gave them and published or broadcast it to the public -- and that a good chunk of that information was in fact propaganda. The argument was made that the media should have stepped back and been more critical of what they were hearing, and perhaps covered those stories in 2001 from a different angle.
But the argument was also made that in a time of war, or for that matter any important political situation, any information given out by the government must be made public. Even if a reporter (like Meryl Streep's character) thinks something is bull, without solid proof or a second opinion that reporter can't justify withholding the information. Yet how much more damage could be caused by publishing something that is almost certainly military propaganda?
I think one of the most valuable aspects of this movie was its 'moral', for lack of a better term: that there are often no right answers. It's great that Hollywood is addressing the issue of ethics and transparency in media coverage of the war, but at the same time, it scares me to realize I'll be dealing with this if I enter into this career.
Monday, November 12, 2007
Tuesday, November 6, 2007
I used to be an academic
I recently had a paper published in an independent student journal, Anthropolitique. It's run by the Anthropological Issues Group (AIG) at Guelph. I originally wrote the paper for my final assignment in one of my anthropology courses, which I absolutely loved and gave me a much wider perspective on the world than I would have otherwise gotten from my undergrad. My prof, Renee Sylvain, told the students running the journal about my paper, so they asked me to submit it. I was so flattered at the time, but I have to give most of the credit to the prof, since a lot of the ideas either came from her lectures or were inspired by them.
Okay, enough mush -- if you're into global indigenous rights activism, or have an assignment to do and would really like to procrastinate instead, go to http://www.uoguelph.ca/~anthro/anthropolitique.htm and click on the Full Online Edition. My paper is first on the table of contents, after the introductory pages.
If you're too lazy to copy and paste the above URL into your browser window, you can also find it in the Links section on the right of this page.
Okay, enough mush -- if you're into global indigenous rights activism, or have an assignment to do and would really like to procrastinate instead, go to http://www.uoguelph.ca/~anthro/anthropolitique.htm and click on the Full Online Edition. My paper is first on the table of contents, after the introductory pages.
If you're too lazy to copy and paste the above URL into your browser window, you can also find it in the Links section on the right of this page.
Saturday, November 3, 2007
Intriguing, this whole Inter-Web thing
I just realized the difference between writing for newspapers, writing on a personal blog that only friends or colleagues will see, and writing on a personal blog that is also career-related and "published" in a public sphere.
I'm not so self-centred that I think a million Canadians will be reading this blog. Nor do I think it likely that a potential employer of mine -- or potential high-profile colleague, as the case may be -- will stumble upon it anytime soon.
But I was three paragraphs into a satirical rant about a certain columnist whose piece I read in today's Globe (or rather, stopped reading halfway through because it was so freaking boring)... when I realized that it's probably not a good idea to post stuff like that on the internet.
Even if it's just my friends and family and maybe classmates who are reading this, so far. Even if perhaps 90 percent of Globe readers would agree with my assessment of said columnist. And even if I'm just a lowly j-school student with no current "real job" prospects.
Even so. As one of our recent online media lectures made so clear to me, the internet can be an amazing tool. It's no longer about the amount of information you can access online -- it's about the fact that you can make all kinds of information come to you, with very little effort. But that also means that anything I post on my small blog could end up in anyone's inbox, for no apparent reason other than that they have an RSS feed tagging anything with the label Journalism or Globe and Mail or Careless Ranting.
All those warnings our teachers gave us about not posting inappropriate pictures or comments on Facebook in case employers saw them are now making sense. But this time it's my own writing that made me think twice: not two days has this blog been up and running, and already I've had to stop and rethink the line between personal opinion and material that I'd feel comfortable publishing in a newspaper.
Interesting.
I'm not so self-centred that I think a million Canadians will be reading this blog. Nor do I think it likely that a potential employer of mine -- or potential high-profile colleague, as the case may be -- will stumble upon it anytime soon.
But I was three paragraphs into a satirical rant about a certain columnist whose piece I read in today's Globe (or rather, stopped reading halfway through because it was so freaking boring)... when I realized that it's probably not a good idea to post stuff like that on the internet.
Even if it's just my friends and family and maybe classmates who are reading this, so far. Even if perhaps 90 percent of Globe readers would agree with my assessment of said columnist. And even if I'm just a lowly j-school student with no current "real job" prospects.
Even so. As one of our recent online media lectures made so clear to me, the internet can be an amazing tool. It's no longer about the amount of information you can access online -- it's about the fact that you can make all kinds of information come to you, with very little effort. But that also means that anything I post on my small blog could end up in anyone's inbox, for no apparent reason other than that they have an RSS feed tagging anything with the label Journalism or Globe and Mail or Careless Ranting.
All those warnings our teachers gave us about not posting inappropriate pictures or comments on Facebook in case employers saw them are now making sense. But this time it's my own writing that made me think twice: not two days has this blog been up and running, and already I've had to stop and rethink the line between personal opinion and material that I'd feel comfortable publishing in a newspaper.
Interesting.
Friday, November 2, 2007
...What next?
So I'm starting another blog. I figure since I've recently become an officially published journalist, I should keep up with the trends and create a "presence" for myself online. (I'm sorry, Wayne MacPhail... from now on, I'll try not to be such a technologically-incompetent 20-something.)
Unlike whatever daily drivel you may see me writing on Facebook, this is going to be where I post any articles or stories I get published in the real world. I'll post the ONE newspaper story that's out there so far -- and just so that one doesn't get lonely, I'll also post my old articles from my undergraduate student paper. This will also have the purpose of allowing me to feel better about myself by seeing the progress I've made in the last two years.
So without further ado... here are the very beginnings of my career.
The London Free Press
Tue, October 30, 2007
Witches favoured over princesses:
Costume choices this year lean toward the dark side.
By MEGHAN MOLONEY, SPECIAL TO SUN MEDIA
Cute is out. Scary and sleazy are in.
The preferences are clear for this year's hottest-selling Halloween
costumes -- and you might be surprised by what girls are wearing.
Or maybe not.
Disney and kittens aren't faring too well at cash registers this year,
say clerks at costume-specialty stores.
More popular -- and likely coming tomorrow to trick-or-treat at your
door -- are the darker, more adult costumes.
At the new Party Packagers store on Southdale Road, manager Michelle
Nemeth says girls' choices have leaned toward the dark side this year.
"The cutesy stuff is not popular. It's more witchy, goth stuff -- the
monster bride, the goth maiden witch."
For adults, she said, "skimpiest sells."
Even costumes for very young girls are more risque. Nemeth points to
Bratz brand cheerleader outfits.
For boys, a big seller has been Optimus Prime of the Transformers
movie -- Nemeth has sold out of them twice -- as well as the classic,
red-outfitted Spiderman.
Men favour the black-suited, bad-guy Spiderman, she said.
Tastes run to the more traditional at Value Village and McCulloch's,
with princess and fairy costumes still favourites for girls.
Crystal Sheridan at McCulloch's said teen girls are still keen on
fairy tales, only they're considerably sexier than the ones you'll see
in the Disney movies.
Boys, influenced by recent movies, have been going for army outfits
and comic-book superheroes.
Tiny pirates also will be sailing the trick-or-treat seas.
Jen Lee, an employee at the Wellington Road Value Village, said these
boys and girls "have probably been inspired by Pirates of the
Caribbean."
Unlike whatever daily drivel you may see me writing on Facebook, this is going to be where I post any articles or stories I get published in the real world. I'll post the ONE newspaper story that's out there so far -- and just so that one doesn't get lonely, I'll also post my old articles from my undergraduate student paper. This will also have the purpose of allowing me to feel better about myself by seeing the progress I've made in the last two years.
So without further ado... here are the very beginnings of my career.
The London Free Press
Tue, October 30, 2007
Witches favoured over princesses:
Costume choices this year lean toward the dark side.
By MEGHAN MOLONEY, SPECIAL TO SUN MEDIA
Cute is out. Scary and sleazy are in.
The preferences are clear for this year's hottest-selling Halloween
costumes -- and you might be surprised by what girls are wearing.
Or maybe not.
Disney and kittens aren't faring too well at cash registers this year,
say clerks at costume-specialty stores.
More popular -- and likely coming tomorrow to trick-or-treat at your
door -- are the darker, more adult costumes.
At the new Party Packagers store on Southdale Road, manager Michelle
Nemeth says girls' choices have leaned toward the dark side this year.
"The cutesy stuff is not popular. It's more witchy, goth stuff -- the
monster bride, the goth maiden witch."
For adults, she said, "skimpiest sells."
Even costumes for very young girls are more risque. Nemeth points to
Bratz brand cheerleader outfits.
For boys, a big seller has been Optimus Prime of the Transformers
movie -- Nemeth has sold out of them twice -- as well as the classic,
red-outfitted Spiderman.
Men favour the black-suited, bad-guy Spiderman, she said.
Tastes run to the more traditional at Value Village and McCulloch's,
with princess and fairy costumes still favourites for girls.
Crystal Sheridan at McCulloch's said teen girls are still keen on
fairy tales, only they're considerably sexier than the ones you'll see
in the Disney movies.
Boys, influenced by recent movies, have been going for army outfits
and comic-book superheroes.
Tiny pirates also will be sailing the trick-or-treat seas.
Jen Lee, an employee at the Wellington Road Value Village, said these
boys and girls "have probably been inspired by Pirates of the
Caribbean."
Thursday, February 2, 2006
CPT Member Speaks Out on Hostages in Iraq
This is the first student newspaper article I ever did that could be described as "in-depth". I was pretty proud of it when it came out at the time. My editor wrote the introductory bit, and we published the piece as a transcript of the interview.
************
The Ontarion - Features
February 2, 2006
CPT MEMBER SPEAKS OUT ON HOSTAGES IN IRAQ
Written by Meghan Moloney, with files from Kim Mackrael
Father Bob Holmes is a Toronto Priest and a member of Christian Peacemaker Teams (CPT), a non-denominational organization of human rights workers who travel to war zones, prisons, and communities in crisis, such as Colombia, Kenora, Hebron, Arizona, and Iraq. The organization's goal is to "reduce violence by getting in the way."
Last November, four CPT workers, Tom Fox, Norman Kember, James Loney, and Harmeet Singh Sooden, were kidnapped by a group calling itself The Swords of Righteousness Brigade.
The group demanded the release of all Iraqi prisoners held by US forces in return for the peacemakers' safe release. After a long period of silence, a fourth video of the activists appeared last weekend with a renewed demand for the release of Iraqi prisoners.
Last Sunday, more than 150 CPT members and supporters walked to the US consulate in Toronto to show their support for the CPT hostages and all Iraqi prisoners held by US forces.
Fr. Holmes is a close friend of captive James Loney of Toronto. Meghan Moloney interviewed Fr. Holmes the day before the latest video was released.
Meghan Moloney: What kind of work do you do for CPT?
Father Bob Holmes: I'm part of the support team, that support our peacemakers in the field. My specific role is coordinating pastoral support – making sure that the peacemakers stay healthy spiritually, emotionally, physically – and I just came back from Chicago, where we did a workshop on trauma awareness and self-care in war zones.
MM: Can you elaborate on how CPT came together and what its philosophies are?
BH: The Mennonite Church was challenged by one of their theologians about twenty years ago, who just confronted them and said, "Look – if we’re going to call ourselves a peace church, we have to be as willing to risk our lives for peace as soldiers are to risk their lives in war." And he challenged them to begin to gather a hundred thousand people who would be trained and ready to go at a moment’s notice into war zones and get in the way, to reduce the violence. And so over the last twenty years, we’ve developed a Christian Peacemaker Team [...] and we’ve got about two hundred who are prepared and trained to do that work. And we think it’d be wonderful if Canada just took the lead and was the first to have an unarmed force of people who were prepared to go into zones and, non-violently, to bring an end to the oppression that’s happening around the world.
MM: What does your organization gain by being non-denominational, as opposed to being affiliated with a specific sect among Christians?
BH: It gives us a much wider reach, in terms of participation. And what happens is, we base our work, really, on the hunger and thirst for justice, and to love your enemies, and so that’s the kind of Christian basics that we operate from, and it’s not based in any one church. What we discovered is that we end up in coalitions with Jewish peacemakers and Muslim peacemakers and secular peacemakers, so we discovered that there’s lots of people who have discovered that non-violent direct action is probably the best way to overcome discrimination and oppression.
MM: Why does the organization choose to keep the word ‘Christian’ as a part of its name, recognizing that perhaps in North America it may draw negative as well as positive attention?
BH: That’s true, and what we’re trying to do is draw the positive to it, and let people know that there are Christians who don’t believe in war, even though some of our neighbours to the South think that Christians should be warriors. And we are certainly not exclusive in the sense that we figure we can do it ourselves – we don’t. We always work in coalition with others. But we draw our motivation from the gospel – we pray, you know, we gather every morning and we worship, and that prayer gives us the courage and the strength and the will to go out and to risk our lives for peace. And so that’s an important thing for us. But we stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Muslims and Jews and seculars.
MM: Concerning the four peacemakers who were taken in Iraq, what were their reasons for going to Iraq specifically, and what was their function there?
BH: Iraq is a place where there’s a tremendous amount of violence, and it’s good for Americans and Canadians to be there because it’s Westerners that have really brought the violence in its present form. The U.S. invasion and occupation has caused a huge wave of violence in that country. So we feel that we ought to be there to do what we can to reverse it and to reduce that violence, and we do that, number one, just by our presence – by being there, and by suffering that vulnerability with the Iraqis, then we are able to speak more authentically when we come back home about what’s really going on there. And secondly, we shine a spotlight on the violence and we’re able to say, look, this is not right, the Geneva conventions are not being observed here, people are being held in prison without charge and without their families knowing where they are for months and months and months, and that’s just not allowed. Sixteen thousand people were being detained when I was there, and I presume it’s a similar number now. So we called not so much for their release but for justice to be built into that system, so that people are charged and have a chance to confront those charges and if they’re not guilty, to be released.
MM: In retrospect, given all of these reasons for their presence, and given what eventually happened to four of them, do you feel that it was still worthwhile – was it the right decision for them to go?
BH: Well, of course. We knew the risks long before we went – we’d been there for three years. Now we were there before the invasion – I’ve been there three times, this was Jim Loney’s fourth time, and I’m sure it was the fourth or fifth time for Tom Fox also. We’ve known this could always happen, so it’s not a surprise when it does happen. You don’t want it to happen, and you fear for it, but you’re willing to take that risk because someone needs to be there, and all the other international groups have left. And so, we end up working very closely with a lot of Iraqi human rights groups, and they’re delighted to have an international human rights organization that they can connect with, because it makes their voice much louder. Otherwise they don’t get heard, whereas now we can be their voice in a much wider area. And in fact, because of the four being held there, our voice has gotten incredibly loud. We are now being heard around the world.
MM: Who are you trying to reach?
BH: We’re trying to send lots of messages to George Bush and his advisors right now. That’s why for these past two weeks we’ve had the Shine the Light Campaign in Washington, DC – every day, there’s a procession from one place of violence to the White House, in order to draw attention to the White House that this war in Iraq is wrong. We've been doing the same thing in Toronto every day also, and going to the US Consulate [...] again to send a message to the United States government that what they’re doing in Iraq is wrong. The occupation is wrong, the detaining of people without charge is wrong, the torturing of people, the abuse of human rights is wrong, and the best thing they can do is get out of there.
MM: So with the final vigil on Sunday [Jan 29], what message do you hope to get across on a global scale?
BH: We want to let the whole world know that occupation can never bring peace, it can never really produce democracy. They’re trying to impose democracy through an occupation – that doesn’t happen, it can’t happen. And we also want people to be very aware that when you detain thousands and thousands of people without trial, that that doesn’t bring peace either. It creates more resistance – in fact, it’s creating terrorists, it’s creating people who are very upset with Canada – well, the United States, not so much Canada. We also really want to call for the freedom of our peacemakers. But that call, of course, is going to those who are holding our peacemakers. We’re hoping that they are very aware of what we’re doing, and that it makes them aware that the people who they are holding are actually people who want the occupation to end, and who want their detainees released, and therefore these [CPT members] should also be released.
MM: Since November, the kidnapping of the four peacemakers has gained global attention from the media. What are some of the critical questions that have been posed?
BH: You know, the typical question you get – "aren’t you being naïve to be there." And our response is no, no, we’re not being naïve at all, we’ve known exactly what the situation [is], we’ve been there three years, we know how dangerous it is. We know that four thousand Iraqis have been taken prisoner and held for ransom, so for us the risk was also the same, you know, we’re willing to bear that risk the same as they are.
MM: Muslim communities have been very supportive in protesting the kidnapping [of the CPT members], including organizations such as the Canadian Islamic Congress. How do you feel about the supportive reaction from Muslims and Iraqis, and how does that impact your efforts?
BH: We were really delighted that our Muslim friends and colleagues of people we work with were able to stand up and say to those who are holding our people, ‘let them go, because these people are really trying to help Iraqis’ –-ordinary, civilian, unarmed Iraqis. And we were delighted that those voices came out so strong, and we had no idea that so many groups were aware of who we were. Some people spoke out for us that we didn’t know even knew about us. But it tells you that they did know, and they did appreciate what we were doing, and they do know we’re non-violent, even though some of the groups that spoke out were not non-violent, they still said hey, these people are doing good work – let them go. So we were delighted with that.
MM: So now that you have the knowledge of that kind of support, does that impact the efforts that you’re making?
BH: Well yeah, I mean our effort – still, after two months – is to try to speak to the people who are holding our four peacemakers, and the only means we have of doing that is through the Arabic media. So we’ve been feeding Al Jazeera and other Arabic sources with as much information as we can, and they’ve been wonderful. They’ve been very anxious to receive it. And they will show the video footage or they’ll voice-over the radio or they’ll translate for the press. So we’re very happy with that, we’ve been getting very good coverage in their media.
MM: Is there one overall thing or one specific result of the whole campaign that you’re really proud of, that you really feel has made a difference?
BH: Well, I’m really proud of the fact that people world-wide right now, from New Zealand right through Great Britain, Canada and the United States, the English-speaking world especially, and the Arabic-speaking world, know that there are Christians who are peacemakers and who don’t believe in violence, [but] who do believe that Gandhian, Martin Luther King style – and I would say Jesus style – of actions are the solution, not violence.
************
The Ontarion - Features
February 2, 2006
CPT MEMBER SPEAKS OUT ON HOSTAGES IN IRAQ
Written by Meghan Moloney, with files from Kim Mackrael
Father Bob Holmes is a Toronto Priest and a member of Christian Peacemaker Teams (CPT), a non-denominational organization of human rights workers who travel to war zones, prisons, and communities in crisis, such as Colombia, Kenora, Hebron, Arizona, and Iraq. The organization's goal is to "reduce violence by getting in the way."
Last November, four CPT workers, Tom Fox, Norman Kember, James Loney, and Harmeet Singh Sooden, were kidnapped by a group calling itself The Swords of Righteousness Brigade.
The group demanded the release of all Iraqi prisoners held by US forces in return for the peacemakers' safe release. After a long period of silence, a fourth video of the activists appeared last weekend with a renewed demand for the release of Iraqi prisoners.
Last Sunday, more than 150 CPT members and supporters walked to the US consulate in Toronto to show their support for the CPT hostages and all Iraqi prisoners held by US forces.
Fr. Holmes is a close friend of captive James Loney of Toronto. Meghan Moloney interviewed Fr. Holmes the day before the latest video was released.
Meghan Moloney: What kind of work do you do for CPT?
Father Bob Holmes: I'm part of the support team, that support our peacemakers in the field. My specific role is coordinating pastoral support – making sure that the peacemakers stay healthy spiritually, emotionally, physically – and I just came back from Chicago, where we did a workshop on trauma awareness and self-care in war zones.
MM: Can you elaborate on how CPT came together and what its philosophies are?
BH: The Mennonite Church was challenged by one of their theologians about twenty years ago, who just confronted them and said, "Look – if we’re going to call ourselves a peace church, we have to be as willing to risk our lives for peace as soldiers are to risk their lives in war." And he challenged them to begin to gather a hundred thousand people who would be trained and ready to go at a moment’s notice into war zones and get in the way, to reduce the violence. And so over the last twenty years, we’ve developed a Christian Peacemaker Team [...] and we’ve got about two hundred who are prepared and trained to do that work. And we think it’d be wonderful if Canada just took the lead and was the first to have an unarmed force of people who were prepared to go into zones and, non-violently, to bring an end to the oppression that’s happening around the world.
MM: What does your organization gain by being non-denominational, as opposed to being affiliated with a specific sect among Christians?
BH: It gives us a much wider reach, in terms of participation. And what happens is, we base our work, really, on the hunger and thirst for justice, and to love your enemies, and so that’s the kind of Christian basics that we operate from, and it’s not based in any one church. What we discovered is that we end up in coalitions with Jewish peacemakers and Muslim peacemakers and secular peacemakers, so we discovered that there’s lots of people who have discovered that non-violent direct action is probably the best way to overcome discrimination and oppression.
MM: Why does the organization choose to keep the word ‘Christian’ as a part of its name, recognizing that perhaps in North America it may draw negative as well as positive attention?
BH: That’s true, and what we’re trying to do is draw the positive to it, and let people know that there are Christians who don’t believe in war, even though some of our neighbours to the South think that Christians should be warriors. And we are certainly not exclusive in the sense that we figure we can do it ourselves – we don’t. We always work in coalition with others. But we draw our motivation from the gospel – we pray, you know, we gather every morning and we worship, and that prayer gives us the courage and the strength and the will to go out and to risk our lives for peace. And so that’s an important thing for us. But we stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Muslims and Jews and seculars.
MM: Concerning the four peacemakers who were taken in Iraq, what were their reasons for going to Iraq specifically, and what was their function there?
BH: Iraq is a place where there’s a tremendous amount of violence, and it’s good for Americans and Canadians to be there because it’s Westerners that have really brought the violence in its present form. The U.S. invasion and occupation has caused a huge wave of violence in that country. So we feel that we ought to be there to do what we can to reverse it and to reduce that violence, and we do that, number one, just by our presence – by being there, and by suffering that vulnerability with the Iraqis, then we are able to speak more authentically when we come back home about what’s really going on there. And secondly, we shine a spotlight on the violence and we’re able to say, look, this is not right, the Geneva conventions are not being observed here, people are being held in prison without charge and without their families knowing where they are for months and months and months, and that’s just not allowed. Sixteen thousand people were being detained when I was there, and I presume it’s a similar number now. So we called not so much for their release but for justice to be built into that system, so that people are charged and have a chance to confront those charges and if they’re not guilty, to be released.
MM: In retrospect, given all of these reasons for their presence, and given what eventually happened to four of them, do you feel that it was still worthwhile – was it the right decision for them to go?
BH: Well, of course. We knew the risks long before we went – we’d been there for three years. Now we were there before the invasion – I’ve been there three times, this was Jim Loney’s fourth time, and I’m sure it was the fourth or fifth time for Tom Fox also. We’ve known this could always happen, so it’s not a surprise when it does happen. You don’t want it to happen, and you fear for it, but you’re willing to take that risk because someone needs to be there, and all the other international groups have left. And so, we end up working very closely with a lot of Iraqi human rights groups, and they’re delighted to have an international human rights organization that they can connect with, because it makes their voice much louder. Otherwise they don’t get heard, whereas now we can be their voice in a much wider area. And in fact, because of the four being held there, our voice has gotten incredibly loud. We are now being heard around the world.
MM: Who are you trying to reach?
BH: We’re trying to send lots of messages to George Bush and his advisors right now. That’s why for these past two weeks we’ve had the Shine the Light Campaign in Washington, DC – every day, there’s a procession from one place of violence to the White House, in order to draw attention to the White House that this war in Iraq is wrong. We've been doing the same thing in Toronto every day also, and going to the US Consulate [...] again to send a message to the United States government that what they’re doing in Iraq is wrong. The occupation is wrong, the detaining of people without charge is wrong, the torturing of people, the abuse of human rights is wrong, and the best thing they can do is get out of there.
MM: So with the final vigil on Sunday [Jan 29], what message do you hope to get across on a global scale?
BH: We want to let the whole world know that occupation can never bring peace, it can never really produce democracy. They’re trying to impose democracy through an occupation – that doesn’t happen, it can’t happen. And we also want people to be very aware that when you detain thousands and thousands of people without trial, that that doesn’t bring peace either. It creates more resistance – in fact, it’s creating terrorists, it’s creating people who are very upset with Canada – well, the United States, not so much Canada. We also really want to call for the freedom of our peacemakers. But that call, of course, is going to those who are holding our peacemakers. We’re hoping that they are very aware of what we’re doing, and that it makes them aware that the people who they are holding are actually people who want the occupation to end, and who want their detainees released, and therefore these [CPT members] should also be released.
MM: Since November, the kidnapping of the four peacemakers has gained global attention from the media. What are some of the critical questions that have been posed?
BH: You know, the typical question you get – "aren’t you being naïve to be there." And our response is no, no, we’re not being naïve at all, we’ve known exactly what the situation [is], we’ve been there three years, we know how dangerous it is. We know that four thousand Iraqis have been taken prisoner and held for ransom, so for us the risk was also the same, you know, we’re willing to bear that risk the same as they are.
MM: Muslim communities have been very supportive in protesting the kidnapping [of the CPT members], including organizations such as the Canadian Islamic Congress. How do you feel about the supportive reaction from Muslims and Iraqis, and how does that impact your efforts?
BH: We were really delighted that our Muslim friends and colleagues of people we work with were able to stand up and say to those who are holding our people, ‘let them go, because these people are really trying to help Iraqis’ –-ordinary, civilian, unarmed Iraqis. And we were delighted that those voices came out so strong, and we had no idea that so many groups were aware of who we were. Some people spoke out for us that we didn’t know even knew about us. But it tells you that they did know, and they did appreciate what we were doing, and they do know we’re non-violent, even though some of the groups that spoke out were not non-violent, they still said hey, these people are doing good work – let them go. So we were delighted with that.
MM: So now that you have the knowledge of that kind of support, does that impact the efforts that you’re making?
BH: Well yeah, I mean our effort – still, after two months – is to try to speak to the people who are holding our four peacemakers, and the only means we have of doing that is through the Arabic media. So we’ve been feeding Al Jazeera and other Arabic sources with as much information as we can, and they’ve been wonderful. They’ve been very anxious to receive it. And they will show the video footage or they’ll voice-over the radio or they’ll translate for the press. So we’re very happy with that, we’ve been getting very good coverage in their media.
MM: Is there one overall thing or one specific result of the whole campaign that you’re really proud of, that you really feel has made a difference?
BH: Well, I’m really proud of the fact that people world-wide right now, from New Zealand right through Great Britain, Canada and the United States, the English-speaking world especially, and the Arabic-speaking world, know that there are Christians who are peacemakers and who don’t believe in violence, [but] who do believe that Gandhian, Martin Luther King style – and I would say Jesus style – of actions are the solution, not violence.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)